Wednesday, September 28, 2016

CFPB Monthly Report Shows Spike in Debt Collection Complaints in August


The CFPB issued its monthly report on consumer complaints this week. The report is a high level snapshot of trends in consumer complaints. Here are the big stories in this month’s report:


  • The three products which continue to yield the highest volume of complaints on a three-month average are debt collection, credit reporting and mortgage. 
  • While the number of debt collection complaints remains almost flat when compared to the same three-month time period for 2015, it’s worth noting that debt collection complaints picked up in volume in August, showing a 50% increase over July.
  • For the second month in a row, student loans indicated the highest increase in change from last year– a 78% increase when compared to the same three-month period in  2015.  Similarly, payday loan complaints continue to show the greatest decrease from last year – an 18% decrease when compared to the same period for 2015; and
  • With all the media reports concerning the Wells Fargo Consent Order, it will be interesting to watch whether complaints against Wells Fargo spike in the coming months and in what categories.  Currently, they are in the middle of “Top 10 Most Complained-About Companies according to this month’s report, checking in at Number 6 with approximately 1/3 of the complaints against them being attributable to bank account/services and credit cards.

Tuesday, September 27, 2016

Bankruptcy Court Shuts the Door on Trustee's Settlement of TCPA Claim


By: Caren Enloe and Parker Dozier
September 26, 2016
A bankruptcy court has dealt a blow to a TCPA defendant’s attempt to moot a class action lawsuit by entering into a settlement with the class representative’s bankruptcy trustee.  In re Presswood, Case No. 12-60237 (Bankr. S.D. Ill. 2016).   In Presswood, the Chapter 7 debtor, a sole proprietor, received two prepetition faxes which he alleged violated the TCPA.  Three years after filing a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the debtor filed a class action for violations of the TCPA.  After filing the class action, the debtor amended his bankruptcy schedules to disclose the pre-petition TCPA claim, valuing the claim at $500 and seeking to exempt it on his Schedule C.   The trustee did not object.  Thereafter, the trustee entered into a proposed settlement with the TCPA defendant for $10,000.00 and filed an application to approve compromise.  The debtor objected, calling into question the trustee’s standing and submitting that the proposed settlement amount grossly exceeds the value of the claim.  Specifically, the debtor alleged that the settlement was an attempt to “buy off” the class action.

The bankruptcy court in reviewing the application to approve settlement first addressed the issue of the standing of both the debtor to object to the proposed settlement and the trustee to settle the suit.  In reviewing the two competing interests, the court noted that, in order for the debtor to have standing, he must have a pecuniary interest in the outcome.  However, “if as posited by the Debtor on his amended Schedule C, the cause of action is actually worth no more than the claimed exemption, the issue becomes not whether the Debtor has standing to challenge the Trustee’s proposed settlement, but, rather, whether the Trustee has standing to settle a suit that is not property of the bankruptcy estate.” 

After conducting a valuation hearing as to the value of the debtor’s TCPA claim based upon two faxes, the court determined that it could not find that the value of the TCPA claim exceeded the $500 exemption claimed by the debtor.  Moreover, the court was troubled by the fact that there were no other class representatives and that a dismissal of the debtor’s claims would defeat the class action in its entirety because the statute of limitations had run.  “By offering to settle the estate’s claim for $10,000, which is over three times more than the highest possible recovery under the relevant sections of the TCPA and twenty times the value supported by the evidence, the Court can only conclude that Pernix is attempting to “buy off not only the estate’s claim but those of all of the other putative class members as well.”

This case is reminiscent of the spate of recent offer of judgment cases. See Campbell-Ewald Co. v. Gomez, 136 S. Ct. 663 (2016).  Defendants’ attempts to moot class actions by settling with the named plaintiff have met the same fate as the defendant in this case.  Ironically, the defendant in this matter had a better chance of the settlement being approved, and therefore the class action being dismissed, if it had offered a lower, more realistic settlement amount to the trustee.  Offering $1,000.00 instead of $10,000.00, which the court found suspect, could have led to the settlement being approved and the class action’s dismissal because the statute of limitations would have been a bar to a new named plaintiff being substituted.

Thursday, September 22, 2016

Wells Fargo is Not the End of the Incentive Compensation Discussion

Prepared remarks and testimony of Thomas J. Curry, the Comptroller of the Currency, to the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs make it imminently clear that cross-selling, sales practices and related incentive compensation will be a focal point for examinations of banks of all sizes and that the OCC continues to review the Wells Fargo matter for "individual misconduct and culpability."  Curry stated that he has ordered examiners to "review the sales practices of all large and midsize banks we supervise and assess the sufficiency of controls with respect to sales practices." Oral Statement of Thomas J. Curry (Sept. 20, 2016). Logic dictates that the FDIC has issued a similar  directive to its examiners, as well. 


Moving forward, the regulatory agencies are also being scrutinized for their part in the Wells Fargo incident.  Congressional leaders are questioning whether the agencies acted quickly enough.  Curry stated in his Testimony that "the actions against Wells Fargo highlight that we must continue our efforts to improve and refine the agency's supervisory program, to sharpen our early warning processes, and to enhance our supervisory capabilities, particularly with respect to our largest, most complex banks."  Testimony of Thomas J. Curry Comptroller of the Currency before the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs (Sept. 20, 2016). 


Banks and credit unions of all sizes should carefully review their sales incentive packages and relevant risk management and audit practices.  As we indicated last week, the Wells Fargo Orders provides guidance as to the expectations of examiners.  Supervised entities should review their product lines, perform independent risk management and internal audits to identify any weaknesses in their compliance management and review their policies and procedures to insure they are consistent with the expectations of examiners..

Wednesday, September 21, 2016

CFPB Provides Some Hints as to First Party Debt Collection Rules

In prepared remarks to the National Association of Federal Credit Unions, the CFPB provided some hint as to what we can expect with regard to first party debt collection rules.  In July, the CFPB released a debt collection proposal regarding traditional third party debt collectors.  At the time, the CFPB stated that it would also be releasing a debt collection proposal addressed to first party debt collectors at a later date.  While the two proposals are being released separately, we expect they will ultimately be addressed in rule making at the same time.


Cordray's prepared remarks to the National Association of Federal Credit Unions indicate that a first party debt collection proposal may be coming soon. Banks, credit unions and other financial service companies can expect the proposal to address the documentation a bank or other lender must provide to third party debt collector prior to any debt collection.  Additionally, Cordray's prepared remarks suggest that we may also see provisions addressed to first-party debt collectors setting forth specific dispute resolution procedures.   



Tuesday, September 20, 2016

New Jersey District Court Rejects Meaningful Involvement Claim


A New Jersey district court has dismissed an FDCPA claim which alleged a debt collection complaint was misleading because the collection attorneys were not meaningfully involved in its preparation.  Lopez v. Law Offices of Faloni & Assocs., LLC, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 124730 (D.N.J. Sept. 14, 2016).  In Lopez, the consumer alleged that the collection firm violated 15 U.S.C. §§1692e and f by filing the complaint “without first having an attorney individually review the file, make the appropriate inquiry and exercise professional judgment.”  Lopez at *8.  In support of her claim, the consumer further alleged that the collection firm filed 198 complaints on the same day that it filed its complaint against her.  The consumer also pointed to the fact that the collection complaint contained a discrepancy in the amount owed, alleging in one paragraph that a balance of $1,000.48 was owed and in another that a balance of $1010.48 was owed. 

The collection firm moved to dismiss and asserted in that the complaint did not state a plausible claim for violation of the FDCPA.  The court agreed, noting that the complaint did not include allegations as to: (a) the number of attorneys employed by the collection firm; (b) the number of attorneys who actually reviewed the complaint; or (c) over what period of time the collection complaint was drafted and reviewed.  Id. at *9.  “Without these details, Plaintiff’s allegations regarding attorney involvement are speculative and do not support a plausible claim for violation of the FDCPA based on a lack of meaningful attorney involvement.” Id.  

The decision continues a string of decisions in New Jersey refusing to extend the district’s holding in Bock v. Pressler & Pressler, 30 F. Supp. 3d 283 (D.N.J. 2014) which has been remanded to the district court for further proceedings as to whether the consumer has standing.  See also Morales v. Pressler & Pressler, 2015 U.S. Dis. LEXIS 49928 (Apr. 16, 2015 D.N.J.); Barata v. Nudelman, Klemm & Golub, P.C., 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 20280 (Feb. 19, 2015 D.N.J.).

Monday, September 19, 2016

Fifth Circuit Weighs in on Time Barred Debt


The Fifth Circuit has joined the growing split in circuits concerning the collection of time barred debt. In Daugherty v. Convergent Outsourcing, Inc., 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 16531 (5th Cir. Tex. Sept. 8, 2016), the Fifth Circuit joined the Sixth and Seventh Circuit in holding that “a collection letter that is silent as to litigation, but which offers to “settle” a time-barred debt without acknowledging that such a debt is judicially enforceable, can be sufficiently deceptive or misleading to violate the FDCPA.” Daugherty at * 7.  

In Daugherty, the collection letter provided that 



This notice is being sent to you by a collection agency. The records of LVNV Funding LLC show that your account has a past due balance of $32,405.91.

Our client has advised us that they are willing to settle your account for 10% of your total balance due to settle your past balance. The full settlement must be received in our office by an agreed upon date. If you are interested in taking advantage of this offer, call our office within 60 days of this letter. Your settlement amount would be $3,240.59 to clear this account in full.
Even if you are unable to take advantage of this offer, please contact our office to see what terms can be worked out on your account. We are not required to make this offer to you in the future.
Daugherty v. Convergent Outsourcing, Inc., 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 16531, *3 (5th Cir. Tex. Sept. 8, 2016). The letter offered three payment opportunities: “(1) a "Lump Sum Settlement Offer of 10%" requiring a single payment of $3,240.59; (2) a "Settlement Offer of 25% & Pay Over 3 Months" requiring three payments of $2,700.49; or (3) "Spread Your Payments Over 12 Months" requiring monthly payments of $2,700.49 over the course of a year.” Id. at *3-4.


In siding with the Sixth and Seventh Circuits, the Fifth Circuit adopted the rationale of the Seventh Circuit- specifically, that the plain language of the FDCPA prohibits not only threatening to take actions that a debt collection cannot take, but also using false, deceptive or misleading representations concerning the character or legal status of the debt. The court therefore concluded that “a collection letter seeking payment on a time-barred debt (without disclosing its unenforceability) but offering a “settlement” and inviting partial payment (without disclosing the possible pitfalls) could constitute a violation of the FDCPA.” Daugherty at *13. The Fifth Circuit reversed the district court’s dismissal of the action and remanded the matter for further proceedings.

For those keeping score.  The Third and Eighth Circuits have held that "[i]n the absence of a threat of litigation or actual litigation, no violation of the FDCPA has occurred when a debt collector attempts to collect on a potentially time-barred debt that is otherwise valid." Huertas v. Galaxy Asset Mgmt, 641 F.3d 28, 33 (3d Cir. 2011) (quoting Freyermuth, v. Credit Bureau Services, Inc., 248 F.3d 767, 771 (8th Cir. 2001). Additionally, the CFPB is considering a proposal that would require debt collectors to provide a disclosure that advises the consumer that the debt is time barred and the debt collector cannot sue to recover it.