Wednesday, November 2, 2016

CFPB Amends its Vendor Management Guidance


The CFPB has amended its guidance on vendor management. According to the CFPB, the amendment was necessary to “clarify that the depth and formality of the risk management program for service vendors may vary depending upon the service being performed – its size, scope, complexity, importance and potential for consumer harm.”  CFPB Bulletin 2016-02.  The Bulletin, like its 2012 predecessor, makes clear that the supervised entities are responsible with their service providers for their service providers’ compliance with federal consumer financial laws. “While due diligence does not provide a shield against liability for actions by the service provider, it could help reduce the risk that the service provider will commit violations for which the supervised bank or nonbank may be liable...”  

 

The Bulletin set forth a number of nonexclusive steps it expects covered institutions to take in managing their service providers:

 

  • Doing due diligence to insure their service providers understand and are capable of complying with applicable consumer financial laws;
  • Requesting and reviewing their service providers’ policies, procedures, internal controls, and training materials to insure their service providers are providing adequate training and oversight to insure compliance with applicable consumer financial laws;
  • Providing contractual provisions in their vendor agreements that provide clear expectations of compliance, as well as appropriate and enforceable consequences for any failure to comply;
  • Insuring that service providers are prohibited from unfair, deceptive or abusive acts or practices, as well as violations of specific federal consumer financial laws;
  • Establishing internal controls and on-going audits and examinations of service providers to insure their continued compliance; and
  • Taking prompt action to address problems identified through the monitoring process, including termination of relationships, if appropriate.

 

Moreover, the Bulletin makes clear that the CFPB takes the position that it has supervisory and enforcement authority over bank and nonbank supervised service providers and “will exercise the full extent of its supervisory authority over supervised service providers, including its authority to examine for compliance with Title X’s prohibition on unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices.”  Service providers and supervised entities alike can expect the CFPB to expand its enforcement net to include entities which are not otherwise covered by the CFPB. 

 

Supervised entities should review their vendor management policies and shore up any weaknesses in their compliance management systems with respect to their vendor management relationships.  Service providers, meanwhile, should be reviewing their own policies and procedures to insure compliance with all applicable consumer financial laws.  Both supervised entities and service providers should review the CFPB’s Supervision and Examination Manual: Compliance Management Review andUnfair, Deceptive and Abusive Acts or Practices.

 

Monday, October 31, 2016

Courts Continue to Draw Line on Standing


A New Jersey district court’s recent dismissal of a single count claim brought under the Fair and Accurate Transactions Act (“FACTA”) reinforces the need for consumers to carefully identify their injury in fact.  In Kamal v. J. Crew Group, Inc., 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 145392 (D.N.J. Oct. 20, 2016), the consumer filed a  putative class action alleging that defendant violated FACTA by displaying the first six digits and last four digits of his credit card on the electronically printed receipt. FACTA, which was passed in part to curb credit card fraud and identity theft, prohibits printing more than five digits of a credit card number on a sales receipt.  The plaintiff alleged that he became more susceptible to fraud as a result of the defendant’s violation of FACTA.

In considering the defendant’s motion to dismiss for lack of standing, the court considered whether, “in light of Congress’ decision to authorize private suits under FACTA, printing ten rather than five credit card digits on a sales receipt elevates the risk of fraud enough to work a ‘concrete’ injury for the purpose of Article III standing.”  Kamal at *6. In determining that the motion to dismiss should be granted, the court found that the amended complaint did not provide facts sufficient to demonstrate a “risk sufficiently ‘actual or imminent’ to constitute a concrete injury.”  Specifically, the court noted that: (a) there was no evidence that anyone had accessed or attempted to access plaintiff’s credit card information; and (b) there was nothing to indicate anyone will actually obtain one of the plaintiff’s discarded receipts and identify the remaining six digits of the credit card number and then attempt to use the card.  Moreover, the court noted that “Congress’ role in identifying and elevating intangible harms does not mean that a plaintiff automatically satisfies the injury-in-fact requirements whenever a statute gives a person a statutory right.” Id. at *10. 

The court’s decision joins a growing body of case law which has emerged since Spokeo v. Robins which refuses to give credence to technical statutory violations without some allegation or indicia of real harm.

Thursday, October 27, 2016

CFPB Turns its Attention to Prepaid Products and North Carolina


The CFPB issued its Monthly Report this week. The report is a high level snapshot of trends in consumer complaints and provides a summary of the volume of complaints by product category, by company and by state. Additionally, each month it highlights a product type and a geographic area. This month’s report highlights prepaid card products and emphasizes the CFPB’s concern for the unbanked and underbanked population. Cordray noted that for the unbanked and underbanked, “prepaid products are a vital source of financial security.”  CFPB Monthly Complaint Snapshot Highlights Prepaid Product Complaints.

 

NATIONAL OUTLOOK. Each month, the Report breaks down complaint volume by product looking at a three month average and comparing the same to the prior year. Student loan complaints showed the greatest percentage increase when compared to the same period of 2015, increasing 96% over last year.  As has been the case in prior months, the Report continues to indicate that the three products yielding the highest volume of complaints on a month to month basis are debt collection, mortgage and credit reporting.  Together, they represent about 63% of all complaints submitted in September.

 

FEATURED PRODUCT OR SERVICE. This month’s report focuses on prepaid cards which, aside from “other financial service”, comprise the smallest percentage of complaints received by the CFPB for September and continue to remain toward the bottom of the list overall.  Put simply, prepaid product complaints make up less than 1% of all complaints received by the CFPB.

 

The most common issues identified by consumers are managing, opening or closing an account and unauthorized transactions or other transaction issues. Specifically, 

 

  • According to the report, consumers complained of questionable transactions being posted to their prepaid cards and claimed their cards were cancelled without notification after they submitted a dispute;
     

  • Consumers also reported difficulty using prepaid cards after purchase and being asked to submit validating documentation; and
     
  • Consumers also complained about receiving prepaid cards as a refund, but being unable to activate the card, access the funds or both.  

NORTH CAROLINA. As it does every month, the Report spotlights a geographic area.  This month, the Report shined its bright light on North Carolina and the complaint trends for both the state and the Charlotte metropolitan area.  For perspective, only about 3% of all complaints received by the CFPB originate in North Carolina.  The most complained of products and services mirror the national picture with mortgage, debt collection and credit reporting comprising the vast majority of all complaints.  As noted by the CFPB, the rate of mortgage related complaints is slightly higher than the national average and it is the most frequently complained of product in North Carolina.

Wednesday, October 26, 2016

Cordray Provides Mortgage Industry with Insight on Examination Priorities


In his prepared remarks to the Mortgage Bankers Association, CFPB Director Richard Cordray offered some insight into his office’s examination priorities with respect to the mortgage industry.    Here are the key takeaways:

  • TRID:  In his remarks, Cordray characterized the CFPB’s early examinations of TRID compliance to be “diagnostic and corrective, not punitive.”  According to Cordray, examiners are focused on the institution’s compliance management system and efforts to comply.  Cordray also indicated that examiners are engaged in transaction testing.
  • Mortgage Servicing: Cordray confirmed that the complaint portal is being used as a partial basis for examinations as it provides a better understanding of trends.  Cordray also indicated that mortgage servicing remains a focal point of examinations and that examiners will continue to focus on the effectiveness of institutional information technology systems.
  • Redlining:  Again, Cordray indicated that this is a “priority issue” in the Bureau’s supervisory work without much elaboration.

Tuesday, October 25, 2016

Timing is Everything: 11th Circuit Finds Loss Mitigation Application Untimely


The Eleventh Circuit recently issued an opinion emphasizing the importance of timing under the Mortgage Servicing Rules.  In Lage v. Ocwen Loan Servicing, the court considered whether the mortgage servicer had an obligation to evaluate a loss mitigation application when, at the time the completed application was submitted, a foreclosure sale was scheduled to occur in two days.  Lage v. Ocwen Loan Servicing, 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 18264 (11th Cir. Oct. 7, 2016).  The consumers contended that the application was timely because the servicer ultimately postponed the sale and the actual sale occurred more than 37 days after the application was submitted. 
The facts of this case are important in that they highlight the complexity of the loss mitigation process.  The foreclosure sale in this matter was originally scheduled to occur January 29, 2014.  On January 8, 2014, the borrowers submitted a loss mitigation application to the servicer which included detailed information about their income and expenses as well as copies of their recent pay stubs, tax returns and other financial information.  On January 9, 2014, the servicer acknowledged receipt and advised that they would notify the borrowers if they needed additional information.  Over the course of the next two weeks, the parties communicated back and forth regarding the loss mitigation application and ultimately, the servicer requested an additional pay stub and indicated that upon receipt, it would evaluate the application.  The pay stub was submitted January 27, 2014 and the borrowers contended that their application was complete January 27, 2014.  The next day, the foreclosure sale was postponed until March 14.  Ultimately, the servicer then requested two more pay stubs and requested additional information, as well.  According to the mortgage servicer, the loss mitigation application was complete on March 7, 2014.  The mortgage servicer denied the application on March 9, 2014 as untimely because the foreclosure sale was scheduled to occur within seven days.  

The consumers filed suit contending the servicer violated the Mortgage Servicing Rules by failing to evaluate the merits of their loss mitigation application within 30 days as required by 12 CFR 1024.41(c).  The district court ruled in favor of the servicer holding that the servicer was not obligated to evaluate the application because the regulation was not in effect when the consumers submitted their application on January 8, 2014 (the regulations took effect on January 10, 2014).
On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit did not address the issue of whether the servicer was obligated to comply with the Mortgage Servicing Rules because even assuming the rules applied, the borrowers’ application was untimely.   The duty to evaluate a loss mitigation application is triggered only “when the borrower submits a “complete loss mitigation application more than 37 days before a foreclosure sale.”  12 CR 1024.41(c)(1).  The court concluded that the Mortgage Servicing Rules require that, in determining the timeliness of the application, the parties should look to the date the foreclosure sale was scheduled when the borrower submitted their completed application.  Specifically, 12 CFR 1024.21(b)(3) provides:

To the extent a determination of whether protections under this section apply to a borrower s made on the basis of the number of days between when a complete loss mitigation application is received and when a foreclosure sale occurs, such determine shall be made as of the date a complete loss mitigation application is received.

The court dismissed the consumers’ contention that the operative date was the date the foreclosure sale actually occurs.  To do so, according to the court, would render the last clause of (b)(3) meaningless.  The court also noted that its interpretation was consistent with the CFPB’s interpretation noting that the CFPB had expressly disavowed the consumers’ position.  “The Bureau recognized that allowing a servicer’s delay of a foreclosure sale to give a borrower greater rights may discourage servicers from rescheduling foreclosure sales and voluntarily considering untimely applications – actions which benefit borrowers…  Stated another way, the Bureau acknowledged that if a borrower’s late application could become timely – and trigger the servicer’s duty to evaluate the application under 1024.41 – as a result of the servicer voluntarily postponing a foreclosure sale then it may be to the servicer’s advantage to proceed with the scheduled foreclosure instead of evaluating the borrower for loss mitigation options.”  Lage  at *17-18. 

Accepting the consumers’ contention that their loss mitigation application was complete on January 27th, the application’s timeliness was assessed based upon the January 29th foreclosure sale and, therefore, the application was untimely.










Monday, October 24, 2016

To Be or Not to Be: The Definition of a Mortgage Servicer Comes Under Scrutiny


For purposes of RESPA, is there a difference to be had between “servicing” a loan and being a “servicer”?  The question was recently addressed by a district court from Florida. Buyea v. Select Portfolio Servicing, No. 9:16-cv-80347, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 140571 (S.D. Fla. Oct. 11, 2016). In Buyea, the consumer submitted a request for information (“RFI”) requesting the identity, address and telephone number of the current owner or assignee of the mortgage.  At the time the request was submitted, the mortgage has been in default for more than a year. The consumer filed suit alleging that the defendant violated RESPA by failing to timely and sufficiently respond to the RFI. The defendant moved to dismiss asserting that it was not a “servicer” at the time the RFI was received and that, to the extent it was a servicer, its response was timely and sufficient as a matter of law.

In support of its argument, the defendant relied upon the definitions of “servicer” and “servicing” provided in 12 U.S.C § 2605. Under RESPA, the “servicer” is the person responsible for servicing the loan. 12 U.S.C. § 2605(i)(2).  Meanwhile, “servicing” is defined as “receiving any scheduled periodic payments from a borrower pursuant to the terms of any loan… and making the payments of principal and interest and such other payments with respect to the amounts received from the borrower as may be required pursuant to the terms of the loan.”  12 U.S.C. § 2605(i)(3) (emphasis supplied). The defendant contended that, at the time the RFI was received, the consumer was 409 days delinquent in his mortgage payments and because the defendant was not receiving mortgage payments, it was not a “servicer” and had no obligation to respond to the RFI.

While the court agreed that the defendant was no longer servicing the consumer’s loan, it concluded that it remained a servicer and was obligated to respond to the RFI.  In reaching its conclusion, the court looked at what it considered to be a key distinction between the definitions of “servicer” and “servicing”: the term “servicer” means the person responsible for servicing the loan.  Therefore, “[w]hether or not Defendant was actively servicing the loan, Defendant remained responsible for servicing the loan at the time it received Plaintiff’s RFI.” Buyea at *10.